Monday, November 16, 2026
FARMERS PITSO AWARDS 2026
24 C
Maseru

Plea bargain notice stalls Lekitla’s trial, again

Business

Lekhetho Makhanya
Lekhetho Makhanya
I am a journalist based in Maseru, Lesotho, renowned for investigative reporting. Over the years, my work has been published both locally and internationally, including in South Africa through the Amabhungane Centre for Investigative Journalism and the Daily Maverick, among other publications. In Lesotho, I have served as a senior reporter for several leading weekly newspapers, including the Lesotho Times, Public Eye, and Sunday Express. My reporting has focused on uncovering issues of public interest, promoting accountability, and giving voice to underreported stories. In 2016, I co-founded the MNN Centre for Investigative Journalism in Maseru, an initiative dedicated to strengthening investigative journalism and fostering a culture of transparency and public-interest reporting in Lesotho.

The murder trial of Democratic Congress (DC) Member of Parliament for Mekaling Constituency, Thabiso Lekitla, has stalled once more in the High Court.

This time the delay follows a fresh plea bargain notice that Lekitla filed through his lawyer, Advocate Lepeli Molapo, last Friday.

Justice ‘Mabatšoeneng Hlaele, who is presiding over the matter, did not hide her frustration with the “late” notice, which came in the middle of an ongoing murder trial. She told Molapo so in open court on Monday.

The judge demanded to know why the notice was filed only on Friday. She said Lekitla and his lawyer had, “during all the material time, had a chance to have filed their plea of bargain notice well before the trial date neared hearing date on Monday”.

A plea bargain is a legal agreement in a criminal case. The accused pleads guilty or “no contest” to a charge in exchange for a concession from the prosecution. It allows the case to be resolved without a full public trial.

“This application was only filed on Friday when the Court was supposed to hear the case today (on Monday),” Justice Hlaele said.

The judge asked Molapo why the application was not filed earlier. He replied that “the New Rules” (Criminal Litigation Rules No. 22 of 2026) had not yet been promulgated when the case started.

The “New Rules” were only “promulgated on 20 March (2026), when this case had already started earlier,” Molapo said.

According to the Criminal Litigation Rules No. 22 of 2026, “a person charged with an offence, or his representative or the prosecutor, may orally or in writing, notify the court of the intention of the person charged with an offence to negotiate a Plea-bargaining agreement.”

The Rules say a plea bargaining agreement may involve:

a promise to plead guilty to a charge in exchange for a recommendation of a lighter sentence;

a promise to cooperate as a witness for the prosecution in exchange for reduced charges, a reduced sentence, or both; or

a plea of guilty to a minor or related offence, a lesser offence, or some charges or counts, in exchange for the withdrawal of one or more charges where there are multiple counts.

Molapo said that when he saw these provisions, Lekitla instructed him to file the notice under the “New Rules”.

Justice Hlaele has given Molapo and Lekitla until 14 December 2026 to prepare and finalise a plea bargain agreement with the prosecution. They must then return to court on that date for a status hearing.

The full trial has been moved to 26 to 30 July 2027. The High Court is expected to be on recess then, but Justice Hlaele said she would hear the case anyway.

“The court remains committed to presiding over this matter to finality,” she said.

She was speaking to the witnesses present in court. She explained in Sesotho, “I will address you in Sesotho, so that you understand thoroughly how the court remains fully committed to presiding this case through.

 “…It is my fiducial responsibility to preside over the cases accordingly. This duty has been conferred on me by the King and I accepted with open heart.”

The judge added that delays that “seemingly” came from the defence were justified.

Lekitla was in the dock throughout Monday’s hearing. He looked and acted casual. When answering the judge, he kept calling her ‘me, a Sesotho word for mother that is unusual in court, especially from a witness in the dock.

The proper way to address a female judge is “Ladyship” or “My Lady”. In Sesotho, judges are generally addressed as Mohlomphehi.

The case had stalled before. In September 2024, Molapo asked to withdraw from the case. He told the court that Lekitla had not properly instructed him and had not paid his legal fees.

Lekitla told the court that Molapo demanded “between M150 000 and M200 000 for his services,” an amount he said he could not afford. He said he was shocked at the cost.

Lekitla also applied for Justice Hlaele to recuse herself. Molapo and Advocate Motiea Teele (KC), who also introduced himself as Lekitla’s lawyer, argued that she was likely to be biased because of comments she made earlier in the trial. Justice Hlaele refused to step down.

In her judgment in October 2024, she said the “double-reasonableness test” was not met. She added that “a fair minded and properly informed observer” would not see bias.

Lekitla appealed. The Court of Appeal heard the matter in October 2025 and dismissed it in November 2025. It sent the case back to the High Court, before the same judge, Justice Hlaele.

Summary

  • 22 of 2026, “a person charged with an offence, or his representative or the prosecutor, may orally or in writing, notify the court of the intention of the person charged with an offence to negotiate a Plea-bargaining agreement.
  • a plea of guilty to a minor or related offence, a lesser offence, or some charges or counts, in exchange for the withdrawal of one or more charges where there are multiple counts.
  • When answering the judge, he kept calling her ‘me, a Sesotho word for mother that is unusual in court, especially from a witness in the dock.
- Advertisement -spot_img
- Advertisement -spot_img

Latest article

Send this to a friend