Friday, November 20, 2026
FARMERS PITSO AWARDS 2026
28.5 C
Maseru

Why dictatorship must never be an option for Lesotho

Business

Newsday
Newsday
Welcome to Newsday Media – Your Trusted Source for News and Insights in Lesotho! At Newsday Media, we are passionate about delivering accurate, timely, and engaging news and multimedia content to our diverse audience. Founded with the vision of revolutionizing the media landscape in Lesotho, we have grown into a leading hybrid media company that blends traditional journalism with innovative digital platforms. Our mission is simple: to inform, inspire, and empower our readers by providing comprehensive coverage of local and global events, current affairs, and cultural happenings. Whether you’re looking for breaking news, in-depth analysis, or captivating storytelling, Newsday Media is your go-to destination for all things news-related. With a dedicated team of journalists, editors, and multimedia experts, we are committed to upholding the highest standards of journalistic integrity and professionalism. We pride ourselves on delivering content that not only informs but also sparks conversation, fosters understanding, and drives positive change in our society. From our flagship newspaper to our dynamic digital platforms, we offer a wide range of multimedia content to cater to the diverse interests and preferences of our audience. Whether you prefer to stay informed through print, online articles, videos, or podcasts, Newsday Media has something for everyone. We believe in the power of storytelling to connect people, bridge divides, and inspire action. That’s why we’re dedicated to providing a platform for voices from all walks of life, championing diversity, inclusion, and authenticity in everything we do. Thank you for visiting Newsday Media. We invite you to explore our website, engage with our content, and join us on our journey to inform, inspire, and empower our community. Together, let’s shape the future of media in Lesotho.

Dr Theko Tlebere

I really don’t understand nor know where this thinking comes from, but there is a dangerous temptation in politics to believe that when a country experiences persistent problems, what it needs is a strongman who can silence disagreement, issue orders and force everyone to obey.

When people become frustrated by unemployment, corruption, political instability and poor public services, the promise of a ruler who will simply take charge can sound attractive. The appeal is understandable. The conclusion, however, is very dangerous, and my fear is the end not the means to an end.

For Lesotho, the question is not merely whether a powerful leader can make decisions quickly. It is whether the concentration of political power in one individual or an unelected group is a price Basotho should ever consider paying for the promise of order.

My argument is that dictatorship should not be entertained as a political solution to Lesotho’s challenges. Before anyone celebrates the idea of a leader who can do whatever they want in the name of national development, we must understand what dictatorship is, how it operates and what happens when citizens lose the ability to question those who govern them.

What exactly is dictatorship? In everyday conversations, a dictator is often imagined as a cruel leader who shouts at subordinates, commands the army and expects unquestioning obedience. Although this image captures some aspects of dictatorship, political science offers a more precise understanding.

Dictatorship is a political system in which governing power is concentrated in the hands of one person or a small group, without effective mechanisms through which the population can hold those rulers accountable or remove them peacefully. Such rulers may come to power through a military coup, an election followed by the dismantling of political competition, or the gradual weakening of institutions intended to limit their authority.

In Totalitarian and Authoritarian Regimes, political scientist Juan J. Linz (2000) explains authoritarian rule through features including restricted political pluralism and the exercise of power within limits that are formally unclear. Put simply, people may be allowed to participate in certain aspects of public life, but they do not possess meaningful power to challenge the ruling authorities.

This distinction matters because dictatorship does not always announce itself with tanks in the streets. A ruler may wear a suit, address the nation in dignified language, promise development and even retain a parliament or courts. Yet, if those institutions cannot meaningfully constrain the ruler, their existence does not necessarily prevent authoritarian government.

The essential question is therefore not whether a leader looks respectable, speaks persuasively or claims to love the country. It is whether that leader is subject to enforceable limits on their power. So, what is the difference between a strong leader and a dictator? 

Basotho should be careful not to confuse decisive leadership with dictatorship. A strong leader can establish clear priorities, enforce laws, demand accountability from public officials and make difficult decisions. A dictator, by contrast, seeks or exercises power without effective accountability.

The distinction is fundamental. A leader who dismisses a corrupt official after a fair investigation is exercising authority. A ruler who can imprison a political opponent merely because that opponent exposed corruption is exercising arbitrary power.

Likewise, a government that enforces public order under established law is different from one that treats every critic as an enemy of the state. The political philosopher Max Weber, in Economy and Society (1978 English edition), analysed legitimate authority and the different grounds on which people accept political rule. His work helps us understand that the possession of power and the legitimacy of its exercise are not the same thing. The ability to compel obedience does not, by itself, establish that a ruler is entitled to govern without restraint.

This is where the attraction of the so-called strongman becomes misleading. A person may be decisive without being dictatorial, and a person may be dictatorial without being competent. Concentrating authority in one individual does not automatically produce integrity, administrative ability or sound economic judgement.

Now, let us look at how dictatorship takes control of society, and leaves it bleeding with disappointment.  Dictatorship is not simply a personality trait. It is also a system of political relationships and institutions.

In their influential book How Dictatorships Work: Power, Personalization, and Collapse, Barbara Geddes, Joseph Wright and Erica Frantz (2018) examine how dictatorships emerge, consolidate power, govern societies and eventually break down. Their research shows why it is important to look beyond the individual ruler to the institutions and political groups that sustain the regime.

The first feature is the concentration of decision-making power. Decisions affecting national expenditure, appointments, security and public policy become increasingly dependent on the preferences of the ruler or a narrow inner circle. Institutions that might challenge questionable decisions become weaker or are filled with people whose primary qualification is loyalty.

The second feature is the restriction of political opposition. Critics may be portrayed as traitors, troublemakers or enemies of national progress. Political parties, civil society organisations and independent voices may face restrictions, intimidation or exclusion. The ruler presents disagreement as a threat to national unity rather than a normal part of public life. The third feature is the weakening of institutional independence. Courts, legislatures, oversight bodies and public institutions may continue to exist, but their ability to challenge the executive becomes limited. The problem is not necessarily that every institution disappears; it is that institutions lose the capacity to say no to those who hold power.

The fourth feature is the use of state power to secure political loyalty. Public appointments, contracts, access to resources and opportunities may become instruments for rewarding supporters and punishing perceived opponents. This creates a system in which citizens and officials learn that personal connections to the ruler can matter more than competence, fairness or the public interest.

Finally, dictatorship can become dependent on coercion. Where voluntary political support is uncertain, rulers may rely increasingly on security institutions, surveillance, intimidation or restrictions on public expression to preserve their position.

Not every authoritarian regime displays all these characteristics to the same degree. Linz’s framework distinguishes among different forms of authoritarian rule, while Geddes and her co-authors demonstrate that dictatorships vary in their organization and behaviour. Nevertheless, the common danger is that citizens lose effective control over the exercise of political power. 

I am definite this was too much to swallow in just one piece, lets pause here for now, next week we shall continue with the most dangerous feature of a dictatorship. The future is NOW!

…to be continued

Summary

  • I really don’t understand nor know where this thinking comes from, but there is a dangerous temptation in politics to believe that when a country experiences persistent problems, what it needs is a strongman who can silence disagreement, issue orders and force everyone to obey.
  • It is whether the concentration of political power in one individual or an unelected group is a price Basotho should ever consider paying for the promise of order.
  • Dictatorship is a political system in which governing power is concentrated in the hands of one person or a small group, without effective mechanisms through which the population can hold those rulers accountable or remove them peacefully.
- Advertisement -spot_img
- Advertisement -spot_img

Latest article

Send this to a friend